No question this is a stone original AU 58. This is not our coin of the week we sold last  month. Different coin-the other looked much different. We fully agree with the AU58+ designation.  This coin has lightly abraided surfaces. The ticks are tiny and are widely scattered. They do NOT damage the coins grade. There is a surprising strong luster. Both sides are a deep original gold with some very light “dirty toning” scattered all over. It is interesting that when using a strong glass, we find NO rub or lines of wear. In that respect, the coin is super clean. Miss Liberty and the details are really well struck. The eye appeal is very original and pleasing! PCGS 66, NGC 151, CAC 33. CAC has only 7 coins beaned higher. PCGS has graded only 2 in AU58+. We just sold the other coin for $9,000.00. The other coin was untoned. This was the coin out of the ANA Stacks sale that brought $7,800.00. Good luck on finding any PCGS CAC MS piece. WE HAVE POSTED THIS COIN AT OUR BEST PRICE